You set up DimScreen, step the dimming up, and watch your main screen go comfortably dark — while your second monitor stays exactly as bright as before. It looks like a bug. It is not a bug, a setting you missed, or a broken download. It is how the program was built, and this short, honest article explains why, and what your real options are for the second screen.
Why the Second Monitor Is Not Dimmed — By Design
DimScreen darkens the screen by drawing a transparent black overlay window. In its source, the size of that overlay is taken from the system’s primary display dimensions — the main screen’s width and height. The overlay therefore exists on the primary display only. It has no second window for a second monitor, no multi-monitor mode, and no setting that extends it. The tray menu, the Settings dialog, and DimScreen.ini (dimming, hotkey1, hotkey2) contain nothing about monitors, because the feature was never part of the design.
This matches the program’s origin: a tiny “1 Hour Software” utility by Skrommel at DonationCoder, written to do one thing — “Dim the whole screen” — in the single-screen era it came from. Version 1.1, dated March 19, 2008, added hotkeys and nothing about multiple displays, and there has been no later version to change that. Any page claiming flawless multi-monitor handling from this tool is describing a program that does not exist.
Your Real Options for the Second Screen
- Use the second monitor’s own hardware controls. Its brightness buttons or on-screen menu are the direct equivalent for that panel. Set it to a level that matches your dimmed main screen as closely as its minimum allows.
- Use system and graphics settings for that display. Windows and your graphics driver’s control panel expose per-display brightness or colour adjustments on many setups. These change that screen’s own output, which the overlay never touches.
- Make the screen you read on the primary display. If most of your dimming need is reading or coding on one screen, set that screen as the Windows primary display. DimScreen will cover it, and the secondary screen can keep reference material at its hardware level.
- Accept a deliberate split. Many people run the primary screen dimmed for focused work and leave the secondary screen brighter for video, calls, or monitoring — where, given the author’s note that DimScreen doesn’t work properly with video windows, an undimmed second screen is sometimes genuinely convenient.
What this article will not do is invent capabilities for other tools to fill the gap. Dedicated multi-monitor brightness utilities exist as a category, but their features change over time and are outside what this site has verified about DimScreen. If you need every screen software-dimmed together, evaluate tools on their own current documentation — and keep DimScreen for what it verifiably does well: simple, fine-grained dimming of the primary display, free, portable, and honest about its edges. The download page links to the author’s original file if you want to confirm any of this against the source included in the archive.
How to Confirm It in Thirty Seconds
If you want certainty rather than reassurance, run this quick check. Set DimScreen’s level to 0% in the tray menu: both screens look normal. Now step it up to a strong level, such as 70% or 80%: the primary display darkens dramatically while the secondary display does not change at all. Swap a window between the two screens and watch it change brightness as it crosses — the same window, dimmed on one display and full-brightness on the other. That experiment demonstrates the design directly: the effect lives on the primary display, not in the window and not in your file. It also rules out the usual false suspects in one pass — a corrupt download would not dim the primary screen perfectly, and a wrong setting would not produce such a clean one-screen-only result.
None of these checks requires reinstalling, editing files, or changing any DimScreen setting — which is rather the point of this article: the behaviour needs explaining, not repairing, and once the explanation is clear the workarounds above are all simple, ordinary display management.
While you are checking, it is worth confirming which display Windows currently treats as primary, in Settings under System and Display. People are sometimes surprised to find the “main” screen is not the one they assumed — especially with a laptop and an external monitor, where the external screen often becomes primary when connected. If the screen that dims is not the screen you work on, changing the primary display in Windows settings is a two-click fix that realigns the tool with your desk, no troubleshooting required.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is my copy of DimScreen broken?
No. Second monitors are not dimmed because the overlay is sized to the primary display only. If your main screen dims and the second does not, your copy is behaving exactly as designed.
Is there a setting to enable multi-monitor dimming?
No. There is no such option in the tray menu, the Settings dialog, or DimScreen.ini. The program has no multi-monitor feature in any version, including the final v1.1.
How do I dim both screens, then?
Dim the primary screen with DimScreen and the secondary screen with its own hardware buttons or system/graphics settings for that display — or set the screen you need dimmed as the Windows primary display.
